In class we reviewed the reading that was started yesterday. In particular we looked at the Alien and Sedition Acts and whether the government should be able to make a law that seems Unconstitutional. While we do not know what they would have ruled at the time the law came to an end before an answer was given. It led however to two states Kentucky and Virginia to basically say they were not going to follow the law Congress had created. This idea of "nullification" takes place when a state basically says they are not going to follow the laws of the land. Similar to what Washington and Colorado have chosen to do over Marijuana recently. We don't really see anything happen to Virginia or Kentucky as well because the laws disappear after John Adams presidency, but leave us wondering who wins, America or a State? To end class we discussed the Marbury vs Madison court case. While overall the event was not really important, it leads the Supreme Court to decide the first case in history. Establishing the idea of judicial review, and forever changing the judicial branch. Questions below go to this topic.
Use pages 118-119 to answer the following along with using the internet as needed. (this was not homework except for question # 6 but was what students were working on)
1. If the Supreme Court
makes a ruling, who’s job is it to enforce it?
2. Why do you think in
the last sentence it says, “That the entire country has with few
exceptions obeyed.”
Why would their be a few exceptions? What does that mean going back to question
# 1
3. How did Marshall both
stick it to Adams and also stick it to Jefferson?
4. Using your own language,
explain what “Judicial
Review" is.
5. How many times
according to book has the Court had to remove or overrule an act of Congress
because of Judicial Review?
6. Go on the web and find
one article about whether
last years "Obama-care" law is Constitutional. Summarize in 3 sentences why it
is Constitutional, and then in 3 sentences why it would not be Constitutional